The Butcher’s Knife
![]() |
![]() |
The Butcher’s Knife
This Story: Season 1 Episode 4 (production code 104)
DSC Overall: Episode 4
Trek Overall: Story 687, Episode 730
Airdate: 8 Oct 2017
Written by Jesse Alexander & Aron Eli Coleite
Directed by Olatunde Osunsanmi
Notes
- Officially this episode’s title is “The Butcher’s Knife Cares Not for the Lamb’s Cry”. Due to the length of that, I just shortened it to three words as that long of a title would really throw off various parts of my blog’s layout.
- To that, it’s the second longest title in all of Star Trek History – with the first being from TOS – “For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched The Sky“.
- Apparently the use of Elon Musk in this episode is a name drop by Jason Isaacs in an attempt to get Tesla to give him a car.
- The first episode with Hugh Culber.
- The last appearance for Rekha Sharma as Landry, as the character is killed off in this episode.
- The last appearance of Michelle Yeoh as Philippa Georgiou – at least in her prime form. Yeoh would make many other appearances as Georgiou – but those are all a mirror universe variant.
- This episode takes place one day after the prior one.
- The first time that Saru’s defense mechanism gets a name – “threat ganglia”.
- A Horta can briefly be seen in one scene in Lorca’s quarters.
- The first time I can think of where it’s stated that Klingons actually eat their defeated foe. There’s dialogue that L’rell & Voq ate the corpse of Georgiou. We’ve had references to them eating the heart of an enemy many times before, but not to this extent.
- The planet Corvan II was previously mentioned in the TNG episode “New Ground“.
- The first of twelve appearances by Jayne Brook as Admiral Cornwell.
- The first time we see Discovery’s (black alert) spore drive in action for a jump.
- Some of the sound effects in sickbay sounded a lot like similar effects in the original series.
Links
[ Wikipedia | Memory Alpha | IMDB | Amazon US DVD | Amazon US Blu-Ray ]#StarTrekMarathon #StarTrek Discovery Episode 4 - The Butcher's KnifeWe get the final appearance of Yeoh's "prime" character, via a recorded message. There's also time spent between Burnham & Tilly and their relationship which was nice. I know what the big plot point for S1 is, but we haven't got
— Joe Siegler (@joesiegler.blog) September 28, 2026 at 3:52 PM
[image or embed]
there yet. There were some laughs in the dialogue too - something I offer as evidence against those who say Discovery is "too dark". We do get the first evidence of a problem with DSC being too advanced to be a TOS prequel tech wise. There's a fair amount of followup w/ Klingons from first 2 eps.
— Joe Siegler (@joesiegler.blog) September 28, 2026 at 3:52 PM
[image or embed]







