• About Me
  • TV Marathons
    • Doctor Who
    • Star Trek TOS
    • Star Trek TAS
    • Star Trek TNG
    • Star Trek DS9
    • Star Trek VOY
    • Star Trek ENT
    • Star Trek Discovery
    • Star Trek Continues
    • Blake’s 7
    • Black Adder
    • Red Dwarf
    • Chef!
  • All My Vinyl
  • Favorites
  • Archives
  • Contact Me
Recent Posts
  • Choose Your Pain September 29, 2026
  • The Butcher’s Knife September 28, 2026
  • Context is for Kings September 27, 2026
  • Battle at the Binary Stars September 26, 2026
  • The Vulcan Hello September 25, 2026
Skip to content
A Cup of JoeA Cup of Joe

Observations, rants, and musings by Joe Siegler.

  • About Me
  • TV Marathons
    • Doctor Who
    • Star Trek TOS
    • Star Trek TAS
    • Star Trek TNG
    • Star Trek DS9
    • Star Trek VOY
    • Star Trek ENT
    • Star Trek Discovery
    • Star Trek Continues
    • Blake’s 7
    • Black Adder
    • Red Dwarf
    • Chef!
  • All My Vinyl
  • Favorites
  • Archives
  • Contact Me
    • Star Trek Discovery

Choose Your Pain

  • byJoe Siegler
  • Posted on September 29, 2026
  • 2 minute read
0
0
0

Choose Your Pain

This Story: Season 1 Episode 5 (production code 105)
DSC Overall: Episode 5
Trek Overall: Story 688, Episode 731
Airdate: 15 Oct 2017
Story by Gretchen J. Berg, Aaron Harberts, & Kemp Powers
Teleplay by Kemp Powers
Directed by Lee Rose

 

Notes

  • The first on screen appearance of the character Harcourt Fenton (Harry) Mudd since the TAS episode “Mudd’s Passion“.
  • To that, it’s the first time Mudd was played by someone other than Roger C. Carmel.  Here he’s played by Rainn Wilson, who is very well known for playing Dwight Schrute in “The Office” (US).  He was also a minor character in “Galaxy Quest“.  Wilson would play Mudd in one other Discovery episode (“Magic to Make the Sanest Man go Mad“) as well as one of the Short Trek shorts (“The Escape Artist”).
  • Mudd’s friend in the Klingon cell is a bug named “Stuart”.  This is apparently a reference to Stuart Bloom from “The Big Bang Theory“.
  • The show references several past Star Trek characters (but they are not shown).  they are: Robert April, Jonathan Archer, Matthew Decker, Phillipa Georgiou, and Christopher Pike.  That is the first live action reference to Robert April (the original captain of the Enterprise NCC-1701), although the character did appear in an animated series episode – “The Counter-Clock Incident“).
  • The first appearance of twenty appearances by Shazad Latif of the character Ash Tyler.
  • The first time the word fuck is spoken in a live action Star Trek episode.

Links

[ Wikipedia | Memory Alpha | IMDB | Amazon US DVD | Amazon US Blu-Ray ]

#StarTrekMarathon #StarTrek Discovery Episode 5 - Choose Your PainWhile on a mission to try and find tech to detect cloaked Klingon ships, Capt Lorca is captured by the Klingons. He's put in a cell with Ash Tyler and Harcourt Fenton Mudd. Mudd is played by Rainn Wilson of "The Office" fame. No one

[image or embed]

— Joe Siegler (@joesiegler.blog) September 29, 2026 at 6:16 PM

will beat Roger Carmel's portrayal of Mudd - but I enjoyed what Wilson did with it. Fun throwback to TOS. Beyond that Saru & Burnham reconcile over the events of her mutiny. We get a nice scene with Stamets & Culber showing just "regular life" - an important scene IMO. Surprisingly talky ep.

[image or embed]

— Joe Siegler (@joesiegler.blog) September 29, 2026 at 6:16 PM

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Donate

Why is this here?

Me


Follow @JoeSiegler
Archives by Date
Featured Posts
  • I, Mudd
    • June 12, 2024
  • George Carlin – Killer Carlin
    • October 19, 2025
  • Reeny / Renée
    • September 11, 2024
Me


Follow @JoeSiegler
Donate
Why am I asking? I don't have any advertisements on this site anymore. I used to, but removed them. You can read why here. Please consider donating.

Twitter Feed
Archives
Created with Wordpress. Using ShadeGarden Theme by Dany Duchaine | Mastodon.
Swim, Swim, Hungry!